Insider Trading: Secrets, Speculation & SEBIs Crackdown

Insider Trading Decoded: The Fine Line Between Smart Insight and Secret Advantage

The phrase that never fails to raise eyebrows on Dalai Street is ‘insider trading.’ It evokes boardroom whispers, secret phone calls, and stocks that soar or sink moments before the news breaks. Mandar Wagh unpacks what truly defines insider trading and explores why it continues to resurface despite decades of regulation, SEBI’s stringent actions, persistent loopholes, and the fine line between legal and illegal trades, while highlighting key lessons for investors.

The Fine Line Between Smart Insight and Secret Advantage

Every investor dreams of being early, but the law draws a strict line between smart research and unlawful advantage. At its core, insider trading refers to buying or selling securities based on material, non-public information that could affect a company’s share price once it becomes public.¹

• The key words are “material trading” (significant enough to influence investors) and “material,” “non-public,” and “(not yet disclosed to the general market).”
  
   

For instance, an executive buying shares knowing a major acquisition is imminent, or a promoter quietly selling holdings after learning a crucial drug trial failed, clearly qualifies as insider trading.³ The decision is based on confidential information. However, if you interpret financial data that’s already public and make a smart bet, that’s perfectly legal. The difference lies in access and timing.

Who Qualifies as an Insider? The Wider Net

A common misconception is that only top executives can be insiders. The Securities and Exchange Board of India’s (SEBI) definition casts a much wider net. An insider is anyone who:

1. Has access to Unpublished Price-Sensitive Information (UPSI).

2. Receives such information directly or indirectly from someone who does have such access.

This includes directors, key managerial personnel, auditors, lawyers, consultants, investment bankers, and even IT staff who handle confidential data. Even a friend or relative who overhears sensitive details can qualify. The law holds both the tipper (the person leaking the information) and the tippee (the person using it) liable.

A History of Insider Trading in India

Insider trading has been a concern since the 1980s.⁴ While the Harshad Mehta scam of 1992 was manipulation-focused, it exposed loopholes that prompted stricter oversight.⁵ Subsequent cases brought insider trading into sharper focus:

• Satyam Scam (2009): Executives and associates allegedly traded shares based on knowledge of the company’s inflated financials before the fraud was exposed.

• WhatsApp Leaks of Quarterly Results (2017): Circulation of unpublished financial results led to stricter $\text{\textcolor{blue}{digital surveillance requirements}}$ for companies.

• IndusInd Bank (May 2025): SEBI ordered action against senior executives for allegedly selling shares while in possession of UPSI regarding major accounting discrepancies.⁶

  These examples underscore that misusing informational power comes at a cost.

The Cost of Crossing the Line

Insider trading carries a heavy price, financially and reputationally. Under SEBI regulations, offenders may face penalties ranging from ₹10 lakh to ₹25 crore, or three times the profit gained, whichever is higher, along with possible imprisonment.⁷

• In July 2025, SEBI fined Rupesh Satish Dalai HUF ₹10 lakh for trades ahead of the HDFC Bank/HDFC Limited merger.⁸

   

• In September 2025, SEBI fined two individuals, Anupam Gupta (₹10 lakh) and Nitin Kumar Garg (₹15 lakh), for trades in Nucleus Software Exports Ltd.⁹

   

Why Insider Trading Still Happens

The risks are high, but the temptation is fueled by human psychology—the desire for quick profits, ego, and the belief in outsmarting the system. The rise of fast digital tools and encrypted messaging platforms has complicated tracking. Insiders exploit various graynon-public” areas and loopholes:

• Mosaic Theory: Legally piecing together small, non-material bits of public information is allowed, but incorporating even one fragment of unpublished, confidential data crosses the line.

• Pre-scheduled Trading Plans: Insiders can manipulate “automatic” trades to conveniently occur just before big announcements.¹⁰

   

• Tip Networks: Using encrypted messaging apps and indirect insiders (friends, relatives) complicates enforcement, though SEBI holds both tippers and recipients accountable.

• Cross-border Accounts and Shell Entities: Used to hide trades, requiring SEBI to increase focus on beneficial ownership rules and international cooperation.graycooperation.

SEBI continually evolves its strategies, utilizing advanced surveillance systems and pattern recognition algorithms to detect fragmented, suspicious trades.¹¹

SEBI’s Insider Watch: A Robust Evolution

SEBI has built a robust regulatory framework to protect market integrity, evolving the Prohibition of Insider Trading (PIT) Regulations over decades:

• 1992: Introduced initial PIT regulations.¹²

   

• 2015 Amendments: Introduced Mandatory Disclosure of Trading Plans and a Structured Digital Database for UPSI.¹³

   

• 2019 Amendments: Rationalized the ‘Connected Person’ definition and strengthened internal controls.

• 2023 and 2024 Amendments: Extended PIT Regulations to mutual fund units and emphasized enhanced surveillance mechanisms and AI-driven monitoring.¹⁴

   

  The introduction of digital audit trails and mandatory structured databases is transforming compliance standards, aligning with global best practices.¹⁵

Clean Trades, Clear Signals: A Guide for Investors

Not all insider trades are illegal. Legitimate insider transactions (e.g., executives buying shares as part of compensation) are common, provided they follow disclosure norms and happen during open trading windows. These must be disclosed to stock exchanges within two working days.

• Investor Lesson: Legitimate insider buying often signals management confidence. This activity can be a smart analytical tool, but it must be interpreted cautiously and combined with broader financial analysis.

• The Warning: Do not mimic insider moves blindly. Also, be aware of information traps like market rumors or social media posts claiming to have privileged information. Acting on unverified data can lead to legal liability, as knowingly using UPSI is illegal, even if you didn’t originate it.

Insider trading is a test of integrity. For investors, the lesson is simple: Markets reward knowledge, but they demand responsibility.

Explore Regulatory Compliance

For deeper understanding of  compliance standards, and ethical investment practices, explore perspectives from standards andRanjit Jha (CEO)—known for research-driven, long-term financial analysis.

To explore how Rurash Financials supports investors with fixed-income strategies, market research, and wealth solutions, visit the official website.